| Academy of Saint Elizabeth | Academy of Saint Eli | A | 12 | | | | |
| Chatham High School | Cougars 1 | A | 7 | Grant Press '25 | | Samantha Wagner '28 | |
| Chatham High School | Cougars 2 | A | 3 | Noah Lin '27 | | Christian Bruno '28 | |
| Chatham High School | Cougars 3 | A | 15 | Cara Lynch '27 | | Bridget Sweeney '27 | |
| Chatham High School | Cougars 4 | A | 5 | Ethan Wagner '26 | | Divyanshi Rath '25 | |
| Chatham High School | Cougars 5 | A | 19 | Cameron Francini '25 | | Rohan Beniwal '27 | 1-2 |
| | Maddie Field '27 | 3-5 |
| Delbarton School | Green Wave 1 | A | 1 | | | | |
| Delbarton School | Green Wave 2 | A | 6 | Jack Tonzola '25 | 1-5 | John Mermel '27 | 1-5 |
| Seton Hall Preparatory School | Pirates 1 | A | 2 | Ryan D'Orsi '26 | | Lazar Maslarkov '27 | |
| Seton Hall Preparatory School | Pirates 2 | A | 18 | Colby Christian '27 | | Dean ROMAIN '26 | |
| Seton Hall Preparatory School | Pirates 3 | A | 13 | Kyle Phillips '25 | | Sankit Upadhyay '26 | |
| Reserves | Lucas Obrien '27 |
| Summit High School | Hilltoppers 1 | A | 9 | Grace Penque '25 | | Tristan Pohl '27 | |
| Summit High School | Hilltoppers 2 | A | 14 | Nikhil Ray '26 | | Charlotte Leck '26 | |
| Summit High School | Hilltoppers 3 | A | 17 | Peter Huntley-Robertson '25 | | Audrey Vargas '28 | |
| Summit High School | Hilltoppers 4 | A | 16 | Elena Carranza '26 | | Evy Elbanna '26 | |
| Summit High School | Hilltoppers 5 | A | 10 | Michael Creel '25 | | | |
| The Pingry School | Big Blue 1 | A | 8 | Avery Hoffman '26 | 1-8 | Joseph Koranyi '28 | 1-8 |
| Blythe Hoffman '28 | 9-15 | Keira DeCroix '26 | 9-15 |
| Jack Shea '27 | 16-22 | Ryan Tarpley '28 | 16-22 |
| Reserves | Isabelle Yeung '28 |
| The Pingry School | Big Blue 2 | A | 4 | | | | |
| The Pingry School | Big Blue 3 | A | 11 | | | | |
