| # | Team 1 | Record | Record | Team 2 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Round 1 | |||||||
| 1 | Christian Brothers Academy Colts | 1-4-6 | vs | 2-3-5 | Ranney School Panthers | ||
| 2 | Rumson-Fair Haven Bulldogs | 1-2-5 | vs | 3-4-6 | Donovan Catholic High School Griffins | ||
| 3 | Donovan Catholic High School Griffins | 3-4-6 | vs | 1-2-5 | Christian Brothers Academy Colts | ||
| 4 | Ranney School Panthers | 4-5-6 | vs | 1-2-3 | Rumson-Fair Haven Bulldogs | ||
| 5 | Ranney School Panthers | 1-2-4 | vs | 3-5-6 | Donovan Catholic High School Griffins | ||
| 6 | Rumson-Fair Haven Bulldogs | 1-2-5 | vs | 3-4-6 | Christian Brothers Academy Colts | ||
| Round 2 | |||||||
| 7 | Christian Brothers Academy Colts | 1-2-6 | vs | 3-4-5 | Ranney School Panthers | ||
| 8 | Rumson-Fair Haven Bulldogs | 1-2-5 | vs | 3-4-6 | Donovan Catholic High School Griffins | ||
| 9 | Donovan Catholic High School Griffins | 2-5-6 | vs | 1-3-4 | Christian Brothers Academy Colts | ||
| 10 | Ranney School Panthers | 3-4-5 | vs | 1-2-6 | Rumson-Fair Haven Bulldogs | ||
| 11 | Ranney School Panthers | 2-3-5 | vs | 1-4-6 | Donovan Catholic High School Griffins | ||
| 12 | Rumson-Fair Haven Bulldogs | 1-2-3 | vs | 4-5-6 | Christian Brothers Academy Colts | ||